Skip to content
The Golden Record Get the Sunday Letter
Menu

Questions / Question 07

Question 07, Strategy path

What rules will tokenised settlement run under when the sandbox or pilot ends?

For strategy, legal and market infrastructure leads at a bank, asset manager or venue who have to decide whether to build tokenised settlement inside the UK sandbox or the EU pilot regime, and need to know what comes after it and when they’ll be told.

Who’s asking

Raised in consultations and talks by

5 public asks, each linked below

Each raised this question in a public consultation, talk or report. We do the research once, grade every claim and keep the answer checked, so every team asking it gets one sourced response to build on.

The short answer

Graded Announced

Not yet. Neither the UK nor the EU has written the permanent regime. The UK sandbox rules lapse on 8 January 2029, and the Treasury’s report on whether it’ll make the tested arrangements permanent has to be prepared by 10 January 2028. The FCA says the end state is still to be determined.

The end dates are in law. The regime that follows them isn’t written in either place.

The end date of the UK sandbox, the Treasury’s reporting date and the six-year limit on EU permissions are confirmed from the legal texts. That no permanent regime has been settled rests on what the FCA, the Bank of England, ESMA and the Council Presidency have said, so the answer is graded announced. How we grade.

Read the full answer, seven paragraphs

Start with the dates that are law. The regulations behind the UK’s Digital Securities Sandbox cease to have effect on 8 January 2029. The Treasury’s report on the sandbox has to be prepared by 10 January 2028, and it has to say whether and how the Treasury will use its power to make the arrangements permanent. Claims 1, 2 and 3.

The power exists and the regime doesn’t. The Act lets the Treasury make the tested arrangements permanent by regulations, with variations, and before the sandbox expires. It also lets one sandbox be replaced by another. What those regulations would say hasn’t been published in anything we opened. In November 2026 the Treasury widened the list of laws a sandbox can modify, which changes the toolkit and leaves the end date where it was. Claims 4, 5, 6 and 35.

The regulators say as much. The Bank of England describes a new permanent regime as the intention, if the technology is adopted. The FCA’s page labels the last stage a possible new permanent regime with a legal designation still to be decided. In September 2026 the FCA said the end state has to be worked out from what the sandbox teaches, and that it’s weighing three routes with the Treasury: extend the sandbox, modify it, or change the wider depository rules. Claims 7, 9, 12 and 13.

When will firms know? The FCA says a joint Roadmap with the Bank of England, with specific target dates, comes later in 2026. We found no published Roadmap on the day we checked. The FCA also warns that some of the work depends on legislation and international processes. Claims 14, 15 and 16.

The EU is at a different point. A permission under its pilot regime lasts up to six years, and each operator has to keep a transition strategy ready. ESMA recommended in June 2025 writing the regime permanently into law and dropping the six-year limit. The Commission has proposed a review, and the Council Presidency’s October 2026 compromise would raise the main threshold to 300 billion euros. The Presidency says the institutions have committed to agree the package by the end of 2026. Claims 21, 22, 25, 28, 30 and 32.

The industry’s complaint is the gap itself. The FCA reports that respondents said the lack of permanence was discouraging investment. AFME wants earlier sight of end-state requirements and transitional provisions, TheCityUK wants a clear route from sandbox to permanent market structure, and ESMA says uncertainty over duration may be putting larger firms off. Claims 17, 18, 19 and 26.

The rest of this paragraph is our assessment and sits outside the graded answer. In the UK, the Roadmap is the first signal and the Treasury’s 2028 report is the first date fixed in law. In the EU, the replacement looks like a bigger pilot regime, and until it’s law each permission runs on its own six-year clock. Claims 33 and 34.

Exhibit 1

The clocks are set. What comes after them isn’t written.

The dates that matter, in order. The bar on top holds throughout. The dashed box is the gap no source fills yet.

Neither the UK nor the EU has written a permanent regime for tokenised settlement into law yet. Claims 9, 12 and 27
Jun 2025 · EUESMA says the EU could make the pilot permanent and drop the six-year limit Claim 25
Later in 2026 · BothThe FCA promises its Roadmap, and EU institutions aim to agree the package by year end Claims 15 and 32
No dates yetWhat the permanent rules requireNo source we opened sets them out. Claims 9 and 12
Mar 2027 · UKThe window to join the sandbox is expected to close around then Claim 10
10 Jan 2028 · UKThe Treasury’s report on making it permanent is due Claims 2 and 3
8 Jan 2029 · UKThe sandbox rules lapse, unless extendedThe FCA’s page gives December 2028. Claims 1, 8 and 11
Oct 2030 · EUThe latest end of the first permission, in our reading Claims 24 and 34

The UK dates and the six-year limit come from the legal texts, graded confirmed. The Roadmap, the EU timetable and the entry window rest on what the authorities have said, graded announced. The last step is our reading, graded speculated.

Exhibit 2

Two temporary regimes, two different clocks

RegimeHow it endsWhat may followWhen firms hearGrade
Digital Securities SandboxUnited KingdomOne date for everyone: the rules lapse on 8 January 2029. Claim 1An extension, a modified sandbox or changed depository rules: the routes the FCA names. The Act also allows permanent regulations or a replacement sandbox. Claims 4, 6 and 13A joint Roadmap promised for later in 2026, then the Treasury’s report by 10 January 2028. Claims 2 and 15Announced
DLT Pilot RegimeEuropean UnionA clock per operator: each permission lasts up to six years from issue. Claims 21 and 23A larger pilot regime. The Commission proposed a 100 billion euro cap, and the Presidency’s text raises the main threshold to 300 billion euros. Claims 28 and 30The institutions aim to agree the package by the end of 2026. Claim 32Announced

The end dates are confirmed from the legal texts. The FCA’s page gives December 2028 for the UK end, where the regulations say 8 January 2029 (claim 11). Whether the EU keeps or drops the six-year limit isn’t in the Presidency note we read (claim 25).

Worked case

Example Markets Ltd decides whether to settle a tokenised bond in the UK sandbox

Example Markets Ltd is invented for illustration. Every step cites the graded claims it rests on.

  1. Count back from the end. The sandbox rules lapse on 8 January 2029, and the window to join is expected to close around March 2027. Claims 1 and 10
  2. Mark the first date fixed in law. The Treasury’s report on whether and how to make the arrangements permanent has to be prepared by 10 January 2028. Claims 2 and 3
  3. Plan for each route. The FCA says it will weigh three routes with the Treasury: extend, modify, or change the wider depository rules. The Act also allows a replacement sandbox. Claims 6 and 13
  4. Compare the EU clock. A pilot permission runs up to six years from issue, and the operator has to keep a transition strategy ready. Claims 21 and 22
  5. Watch for the Roadmap. The FCA says it will carry specific target dates. We found none published on the day we checked. Claims 14 and 15

Ask your board: if no permanent regime exists by 8 January 2029, does the business case still hold? Claims 1, 17 and 33

How a sandbox or pilot turns into a permanent regime, step by step, in words

  1. A temporary legal space is opened. In the UK the Treasury can make regulations to test a way of running market infrastructure for a limited period. In the EU, operators get a permission under the pilot regime, which covers trading and settlement systems built on distributed ledger technology, a shared database that several firms keep in step. Claims 1 and 21.
  2. The clock is set in the legal text. The UK regulations lapse on 8 January 2029. An EU permission is valid for up to six years from the day it’s issued, so each operator has its own end date. Claims 1, 21 and 23.
  3. A review is required before the end. The Treasury has to prepare a report by 10 January 2028 on whether and how it will make the arrangements permanent. ESMA delivered its review of the EU pilot in June 2025 and recommended making it permanent. Claims 2, 3 and 25.
  4. The permanent rules need new law. In the UK that means Treasury regulations, which can be made before the sandbox expires. In the EU it means an amending regulation agreed by the Council and the Parliament, and the Presidency says the institutions aim to agree the package by the end of 2026. Claims 4, 5 and 32.
  5. If the law isn’t ready, the fallback is more time or a wind-down. The Bank of England says the Treasury may extend the sandbox through legislation. EU operators have to keep a transition strategy ready to deploy. Claims 8 and 22.
  6. Firms hear in stages. In the UK the first stage is the Roadmap the FCA has promised for later in 2026, and the window to join the sandbox is expected to close around March 2027. Claims 10, 14 and 15.

Taking this to a committee?

We turn the most requested questions into Briefs: the working behind the answer, as files you can edit, such as a decision page, a cost model, questions for providers and slides for the committee. This answer stays free either way.

The evidence, all 35 claims

Nine claims are confirmed, 24 claims are announced and two claims are speculated. The confirmed claims are legal texts: the UK sandbox regulations, the November 2026 regulations that widen the sandbox powers, three sections of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2023, and the EU pilot regime regulation. Everything about what comes next is graded announced, because it rests on what an authority or an industry body has said: the FCA’s feedback statement and web page, the Bank of England’s page, ESMA’s review report, the ECB’s bulletin, a Council Presidency note and three consultation responses. We read the EU regulation’s Articles 7 to 9 in this run but the page cut off before Article 14, the review clause, so the review process is cited from ESMA and the ECB and not from the article itself.

Each claim has its own link, so you can cite it. Sources were opened on 21 November 2026. How we grade.

  • 9confirmed
  • 24announced
  • 2speculated
  1. 01Confirmed

    The regulations that create the UK’s Digital Securities Sandbox say they cease to have effect on 8 January 2029.

    The Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 (Digital Securities Sandbox) Regulations 2023, SI 2023/1398

  2. 02Confirmed

    The same regulations set 10 January 2028 as the date by which the Treasury’s report on the sandbox must be prepared.

    The Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 (Digital Securities Sandbox) Regulations 2023, SI 2023/1398

  3. 03Confirmed

    The Act behind the sandbox says that report must state whether, and how, the Treasury proposes to use its power to make the tested arrangements permanent.

    Financial Services and Markets Act 2023, section 14

  4. 04Confirmed

    The Act lets the Treasury make the sandbox arrangements permanent by regulations, either as tested or with the variations it thinks appropriate.

    Financial Services and Markets Act 2023, section 15

  5. 05Confirmed

    Those permanent regulations can be made before the sandbox expires as well as after it.

    Financial Services and Markets Act 2023, section 15

Show all 35 claims
  1. 06Confirmed

    The Act also allows one sandbox to be replaced by another of the same or similar effect.

    Financial Services and Markets Act 2023, section 13

  2. 07Announced

    The Bank of England says the intention at the end of the sandbox is that interested participants can move to a new permanent regime, if the technology is successfully adopted.

    Bank of England: Digital Securities Sandbox

  3. 08Announced

    The Bank of England says the sandbox may be extended by the Treasury through legislation if more time is needed to move to a new regime.

    Bank of England: Digital Securities Sandbox

  4. 09Announced

    The FCA’s page on the sandbox lists the last stage as a possible new permanent regime and gives its legal designation as to be decided, or a new category of market infrastructure.

    FCA: Digital Securities Sandbox

  5. 10Announced

    The FCA says the window for applying to join the sandbox is expected to close around March 2027, so that regulators and firms can prepare for a possible permanent regime.

    FCA: Digital Securities Sandbox

  6. 11Announced

    The FCA’s page gives the end of the sandbox as December 2028, where the regulations say 8 January 2029.

    FCA: Digital Securities Sandbox

  7. 12Announced

    In its September 2026 feedback statement the FCA says the end state for firms leaving the sandbox still has to be worked out from what the sandbox teaches.

    FCA: FS26/1, Tokenisation in Wholesale Financial Markets, September 2026

  8. 13Announced

    The FCA says it will consider with the Treasury three routes: extending the sandbox, modifying it further, or changing the wider rules for securities depositories.

    FCA: FS26/1, Tokenisation in Wholesale Financial Markets, September 2026

  9. 14Announced

    The FCA says the joint Roadmap with the Bank of England will set out how they intend to take wholesale tokenisation forward, with specific target dates.

    FCA: FS26/1, Tokenisation in Wholesale Financial Markets, September 2026

  10. 15Announced

    The FCA says the Roadmap will be published later in 2026.

    FCA: FS26/1, Tokenisation in Wholesale Financial Markets, September 2026

  11. 16Announced

    The FCA says some of the work depends on things outside its control, such as domestic legislation and international processes.

    FCA: FS26/1, Tokenisation in Wholesale Financial Markets, September 2026

  12. 17Announced

    The FCA reports that respondents said the lack of a permanent regime was discouraging investment, and that the most common example was a long-term model for settlement after the sandbox.

    FCA: FS26/1, Tokenisation in Wholesale Financial Markets, September 2026

  13. 18Announced

    AFME says firms need earlier sight of the end-state requirements, the timelines and any transitional provisions, to avoid a cliff edge between the sandbox and ordinary authorisation.

    AFME: response to the FCA and Bank of England call for input on the future of tokenisation, July 2026

  14. 19Announced

    TheCityUK says firms need greater certainty on how a successful use case moves from a sandbox into a permanent regulated market structure.

    TheCityUK: response to the FCA and Bank of England call for input on the future of tokenisation, July 2026

  15. 20Announced

    The FIA says early and clear regulatory guidance will be critical for investment decisions and for scaling from pilots to production.

    FIA: response to the FCA and Bank of England call for input on the future of tokenisation, 2 July 2026

  16. 21Confirmed

    Under the EU’s pilot regime for market infrastructure built on distributed ledgers, a permission to operate is valid for up to six years from the day it’s issued.

    Regulation (EU) 2022/858, Articles 7, 8 and 9

  17. 22Confirmed

    The same regulation makes each operator keep a transition strategy that’s ready to deploy in time, for reducing or leaving the activity.

    Regulation (EU) 2022/858, Articles 7, 8 and 9

  18. 23Announced

    The ECB says the EU regulation itself has no end date, but the permissions under it are limited to six years.

    ECB Macroprudential Bulletin 33, April 2026: tokenisation and the Eurosystem policy response

  19. 24Announced

    ESMA’s review report lists the first permission under the pilot regime as starting on 11 October 2024.

    ESMA: Report on the functioning and review of the DLT Pilot Regime, 25 June 2025

  20. 25Announced

    ESMA says in its June 2025 review that the EU could start by writing the pilot regime permanently into law and removing the six-year limit on licences.

    ESMA: Report on the functioning and review of the DLT Pilot Regime, 25 June 2025

  21. 26Announced

    ESMA says uncertainty about how long the regime lasts may be putting larger firms off committing significant resources.

    ESMA: Report on the functioning and review of the DLT Pilot Regime, 25 June 2025

  22. 27Announced

    ESMA says that if the pilot succeeds it could be made permanent by amending the EU’s financial services legislation.

    ESMA: DLT Pilot Regime

  23. 28Announced

    The ECB says the European Commission has proposed a review of the pilot regime, inside its wider market integration and supervision package, that would raise the cap on the value of instruments to 100 billion euros.

    ECB Macroprudential Bulletin 33, April 2026: tokenisation and the Eurosystem policy response

  24. 29Announced

    The ECB says the mismatch between demanding authorisation requirements and the limited, temporary activity allowed weakens the economic case for joining the pilot.

    ECB Macroprudential Bulletin 33, April 2026: tokenisation and the Eurosystem policy response

  25. 30Announced

    The Council Presidency says its compromise text of 5 October 2026 raises the main threshold of the pilot regime to 300 billion euros.

    Council of the EU: Presidency note 13777/26 on the Market Integration and Supervision Package, 5 October 2026

  26. 31Announced

    The same Presidency note says its text clarifies the rules for entering, operating within and moving out of the regime.

    Council of the EU: Presidency note 13777/26 on the Market Integration and Supervision Package, 5 October 2026

  27. 32Announced

    The Presidency note says the EU institutions have committed to reach agreement on the package by the end of 2026.

    Council of the EU: Presidency note 13777/26 on the Market Integration and Supervision Package, 5 October 2026

  28. 33Speculated

    Not confirmed: this is our own reading. No permanent regime for tokenised settlement is written in the UK today. The first place a firm will see dates is the Roadmap, and the one date fixed in law is the Treasury’s report, to be prepared by 10 January 2028, a year before the sandbox rules lapse.

    Our assessment, from claims 01, 02, 03, 12, 13 and 14

  29. 34Speculated

    Not confirmed: this is our own reading. In the EU the replacement is being written as a larger version of the pilot regime itself. Until that’s law, the six-year clock runs on each permission separately, so one issued in October 2024 runs to October 2030 at the latest.

    Our assessment, from claims 21, 24, 25, 28 and 30

  30. 35Confirmed

    Regulations the Treasury made on 18 November 2026 add further enactments, the Insolvency Act 1986 among them, to the list a sandbox can modify. They amend that list and nothing else.

    The Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 (Addition of Relevant Enactments) Regulations 2026, SI 2026/1215

Who asked, and where

Every place we found this question raised in public, with a link you can open. We add new asks as we find them.

  • AFMEResponse to the FCA and Bank of England call for input: earlier visibility on end-state requirements, timelines and transitional provisions, to avoid a cliff edge after the sandboxJul 2026 · open
  • TheCityUKResponse to the FCA and Bank of England call for input: how successful use cases move from sandbox environments into permanent regulated market structuresJul 2026 · open
  • FIAResponse to the FCA and Bank of England call for input: early and clear regulatory guidance so firms can make investment decisions and scale from pilots to productionJul 2026 · open
  • ISDA and GDFJoint response to the FCA and Bank of England call for input: regulatory clarity on existing rules, for example through Dear CEO letters, in place of new rulemakingJul 2026 · open
  • FCAFS26/1, the summary of responses: the most common example firms gave was the need for a long-term model for tokenised asset settlement after the sandboxSep 2026 · open

Open points

  • What the UK’s permanent regime will require. No source we opened sets out its rules, and the FCA’s page still lists the legal designation as to be decided.
  • Whether the FCA and Bank of England Roadmap has a date for the end state. FS26/1 promises the Roadmap later in 2026, press reports say it’s due in November, and we found no published Roadmap on 21 November 2026.
  • Whether the Treasury will extend the sandbox past 8 January 2029. The Bank of England says it may, and no source we opened says it will.
  • Whether the Council adopted the Presidency’s compromise as its position, and what the European Parliament’s position is. We opened the Presidency note of 5 October 2026 and not the record of the ministers’ meeting that followed.
  • Whether the EU’s amended regime keeps or removes the six-year limit on permissions. ESMA recommended removing it, and the Presidency note we read doesn’t say.
  • The text of Article 14 of the EU regulation, and the date the Treasury’s report has to be published. The page we opened cut off before Article 14, and the Act sets a date for preparing the report but none for laying it before Parliament.
  • Why the FCA’s page gives December 2028 as the end of the sandbox when the regulations say 8 January 2029.

What would change this answer

The FCA and Bank of England Roadmap, the Treasury’s report, to be prepared by 10 January 2028, Treasury regulations that make the sandbox arrangements permanent or extend them, or final agreement between the Council and the European Parliament on the amended pilot regime would each change this answer.

This page is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Corrections are dated on this page and logged in the corrections log.

Written by

Mac Sibbs

Data governance practitioner and investor. The Golden Record reads market infrastructure as governed data, asking who owns the record, how fresh it is and whether two systems agree on it.

Found an error?

Tell us, and we’ll fix it in public.

Corrections go on this page, dated, and are credited by name if you’d like. Review status: Not yet externally reviewed.

Cite this page

Mac Sibbs, “What rules will tokenised settlement run under when the sandbox or pilot ends?”, The Golden Record, last checked 21 November 2026, https://thegoldenrecord.xyz/questions/what-replaces-the-sandbox-for-tokenised-settlement