Skip to content
The Golden Record Get the Sunday Letter
Menu

Questions / Question 04

Question 04, Strategy path

Are tokenised versions of our shares already trading without us?

For the board, general counsel and investor relations lead of a listed company who’ve heard that tokens of their shares exist and need to know whether that’s true, who made them and what the holders can claim.

  • Last checked 19 November 2026
  • 33 claims graded
  • By Mac Sibbs

The short answer

Possibly. SEC staff describe tokens of securities from third parties unaffiliated with the issuer, and Kraken says its xStocks aren’t sponsored by the underlying issuer. DTCC says its tokenization service launched on 28 October 2026, integrated with Canton, under an SEC staff letter covering Russell 1000 stocks.

There are two routes. In the first, a third party issues its own token. SEC staff describe a custodial kind, where the token stands for shares held in custody, and a synthetic kind, where the third party issues its own security linked to yours. Kraken’s xStocks are a live example of a third party’s token, and Kraken says holders have no ownership in the underlying shares. Robinhood Europe’s terms for its private company stock tokens show the synthetic kind, and they say those tokens aren’t shares of any companies. Claims 1, 2, 3, 23, 26 and 27.

The second route runs through the market’s own plumbing. The SEC staff’s letter says DTC’s participants can elect to have their entitlements to DTC-held securities recorded as tokens, and that only DTC participants can register wallets. DTCC says the letter authorises DTC to tokenize Russell 1000 constituents, and that the service is integrated with Canton. The SEC has approved a Nasdaq rule under which a tokenized share has to be fungible with the traditional one and carry the same rights. Claims 9, 11, 13, 14, 18 and 19.

The rest of this paragraph is our assessment and sits outside the graded answer. We found no step in what we read where the listed company agrees to either route. DTCC’s release names no security and gives no volume. It says limited-production trades were completed, without saying in which securities. So these sources show a service that can make tokens of Russell 1000 shares, and they don’t show whether yours are among them. And on Canton you can’t find out by looking, because holdings are private. You have to ask DTC, your transfer agent or the registry. Claims 32 and 33.

A token tied to your shares can come from two places: a third party that wraps or mirrors them, or a DTC participant that elects to have its entitlement recorded on a ledger.

We grade this answer announced. The third-party route comes from an SEC staff statement, which is graded confirmed, and from Kraken’s own disclosure. The DTC route rests on the SEC staff’s letter, which repeats DTC’s description, and on DTCC’s press release. So the answer is graded announced. Whether a token of your own shares exists today isn’t something these sources show. How we grade.

Taking this to a committee?

We turn the most requested answers into Briefs: the working behind the answer, as files you can edit. This answer stays free either way.

How to find out what exists in your name

  1. Sort what you find into the SEC staff’s two kinds. One is tokenized by or for the issuer. The other is tokenized by a third party with no tie to the issuer. If your company didn’t do it, you’re in the second kind. Claim 1.
  2. For a third party’s token, read its terms to see which model you face. A custodial token stands for shares held in custody. A synthetic one is the third party’s own security, and SEC staff say it’s no obligation of yours. Kraken says xStocks holders have no ownership in the underlying shares, and Robinhood Europe says its private company stock tokens are derivative contracts. Claims 2, 3, 23 and 26.
  3. Check whether you’re in the Russell 1000. The SEC staff’s letter says the first version of DTC’s service is limited to securities in that index at the time the version launches, plus US Treasury securities and ETFs that track major indices. DTC is the depository that holds most US listed shares on behalf of brokers and banks. Claim 8.
  4. Know what a DTC token is. It records a participant’s entitlement to shares DTC already holds. The shares stay registered to Cede & Co., DTC’s nominee, and only DTC participants can register wallets. DTCC calls the tokens digital twins and says they keep the rights of the originals. Claims 9, 10, 11 and 16.
  5. Don’t expect to see it on Canton. The Canton Network is the ledger DTCC says its service is integrated with, and it only shows a transaction to the parties with a stake in it. Under CIP-0056, the network’s token standard (a CIP is a Canton Improvement Proposal, the network’s way of agreeing a standard), each asset’s registry keeps the private holding records. So ask DTC or the registry. Claims 13, 30, 31 and 33.
  6. Watch the exchange side. Under the Nasdaq rule the SEC approved in March 2026, a participant flags an order for tokenized form, and the tokenized share has to carry the same CUSIP and the same rights as the traditional one. Claims 17, 18, 19 and 20.

Exhibit 1

Three things that can carry your company’s name

Kind 1

A third party’s custodial token

A third party holds shares in custody and issues a token that stands for them. Kraken says xStocks holders have no ownership in the underlying shares. Claims 2 and 23.

Trade-off. Ask: who is the issuer, where are the shares held, and what do holders get if it fails?

Kind 2

A third party’s synthetic token

The third party issues its own security or derivative linked to a company’s shares. SEC staff say a linked security is no obligation of the referenced issuer. Robinhood Europe’s private company stock tokens are derivative contracts. Claims 3 and 26.

Trade-off. Ask: do the terms and the marketing make clear it isn’t your share?

Kind 3

A DTC digital twin

A DTC participant has its entitlement to DTC-held shares recorded as a token. The shares stay registered to Cede & Co., and DTCC says the rights are retained. Claims 9, 10 and 16.

Trade-off. Ask: has DTC tokenized any entitlements in our shares, and on which network?

The first two kinds follow the SEC staff statement, which describes US law and carries no legal force. The third follows the SEC staff’s letter to DTC and DTCC’s own release.

The evidence, all 33 claims

Eleven claims are confirmed, 20 claims are announced and two claims are speculated. The confirmed claims are an SEC staff statement, which carries no legal force, and an SEC order approving a Nasdaq rule. What DTC’s service does is graded announced, because the SEC staff’s letter repeats DTC’s own description and the launch facts come from DTCC’s release. What Kraken, Robinhood Europe and Canton’s documents say about their own products is announced. The ESMA item is a speech. No source here is a court ruling.

Each claim has its own link, so you can cite it. Sources were opened on 19 November 2026. How we grade.

  1. 01Confirmed

    SEC staff describe two kinds of tokenized security: those tokenized by or for the issuer, and those tokenized by third parties unaffiliated with the issuer.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  2. 02Confirmed

    In the custodial model SEC staff describe, the third party issues a crypto asset that represents an underlying security held in custody.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  3. 03Confirmed

    SEC staff describe a synthetic model too, where the third party issues its own security linked to yours. The staff say that linked security is no obligation of the issuer of the referenced security.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  4. 04Confirmed

    SEC staff say a third party’s token may or may not give its holder any rights as a holder of the underlying security.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  5. 05Confirmed

    SEC staff say holders of a third party’s token may be exposed to that third party’s risks, such as its bankruptcy.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  6. 06Confirmed

    Where a third party’s token is a security-based swap, SEC staff say it can’t be offered or sold to people who aren’t eligible contract participants unless a registration statement is in effect and trades happen on a national securities exchange.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  7. 07Confirmed

    The SEC statement is a staff view. Its own footnote says staff statements have no legal force or effect.

    SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026

  8. 08Announced

    The SEC staff’s no-action letter to DTC, the US central securities depository, says on DTC’s stated facts that the first version of its tokenization service is limited to Russell 1000 securities, US Treasury securities and ETFs that track major indices.

    SEC staff no-action letter to DTC on its tokenization services, 11 December 2025

  9. 09Announced

    The same letter says the service would let DTC’s participants elect to have their security entitlements to DTC-held securities recorded on a distributed ledger.

    SEC staff no-action letter to DTC on its tokenization services, 11 December 2025

  10. 10Announced

    The same letter says the securities behind the tokens would stay registered in the name of Cede & Co., DTC’s nominee.

    SEC staff no-action letter to DTC on its tokenization services, 11 December 2025

  11. 11Announced

    The same letter says only DTC participants would be permitted to register wallets.

    SEC staff no-action letter to DTC on its tokenization services, 11 December 2025

  12. 12Announced

    DTCC said on 28 October 2026 that it had launched the DTCC Tokenization Service that day.

    DTCC: DTCC Tokenization Service Goes Live, 28 October 2026

  13. 13Announced

    DTCC said the service is integrated with the Canton Network and with DTCC’s private Besu network.

    DTCC: DTCC Tokenization Service Goes Live, 28 October 2026

  14. 14Announced

    DTCC said an SEC staff no-action letter authorises DTC to tokenize Russell 1000 constituents, exchange-traded funds that track major indices and US Treasury securities.

    DTCC: DTCC Tokenization Service Goes Live, 28 October 2026

  15. 15Announced

    DTCC said 20 DTC participants had signed agreements to access the service by launch day.

    DTCC: DTCC Tokenization Service Goes Live, 28 October 2026

  16. 16Announced

    DTCC said the tokenized securities, which it calls digital twins, retain the ownership rights, investor protections and economic entitlements of the originals.

    DTCC: DTCC Tokenization Service Goes Live, 28 October 2026

  17. 17Confirmed

    The SEC approved Nasdaq’s rule change to trade tokenized versions of certain equity securities and exchange traded products, in an order dated 18 March 2026.

    SEC order approving Nasdaq’s rule change on trading tokenized securities, Release No. 34-105047, Federal Register, 23 March 2026

  18. 18Confirmed

    Under the approved Nasdaq rule, a tokenized share has to be fungible with the traditional share and carry the same CUSIP number and trading symbol.

    SEC order approving Nasdaq’s rule change on trading tokenized securities, Release No. 34-105047, Federal Register, 23 March 2026

  19. 19Confirmed

    Under the approved Nasdaq rule, a tokenized share has to give its holders the same rights and privileges as a share of the equivalent class of the traditional security.

    SEC order approving Nasdaq’s rule change on trading tokenized securities, Release No. 34-105047, Federal Register, 23 March 2026

  20. 20Confirmed

    Under the approved Nasdaq rule, a DTC Eligible Participant that wants a trade settled in tokenized form has to flag that preference when it enters the order.

    SEC order approving Nasdaq’s rule change on trading tokenized securities, Release No. 34-105047, Federal Register, 23 March 2026

  21. 21Announced

    Better Markets, a commenter quoted in the SEC’s order, said tokenized stocks may be issued by a third party and that it’s unclear with whom investors are investing.

    SEC order approving Nasdaq’s rule change on trading tokenized securities, Release No. 34-105047, Federal Register, 23 March 2026

  22. 22Announced

    Kraken’s risk disclosure says xStocks, its tokenized stock product, are issued by Backed Assets (JE) Limited, a Jersey company.

    Kraken: xStocks Risk Disclosure

  23. 23Announced

    Kraken’s risk disclosure says holders of xStocks have no ownership in the underlying stock or shares.

    Kraken: xStocks Risk Disclosure

  24. 24Announced

    Kraken’s risk disclosure says xStocks aren’t sponsored, supported or promoted by the issuer or sponsor of the underlying.

    Kraken: xStocks Risk Disclosure

  25. 25Announced

    Kraken’s FAQ says xStocks can be withdrawn to a compatible wallet on Solana, Ethereum, TON or Ink.

    Kraken Support: xStocks Frequently Asked Questions

  26. 26Announced

    Robinhood Europe’s terms for a giveaway of its private company stock tokens say those stock tokens are financial derivative contracts between the customer and Robinhood.

    Robinhood Europe: Private Stock Giveaway Promotion Terms and Conditions (EU)

  27. 27Announced

    The same Robinhood Europe terms say private company stock tokens aren’t shares of any companies.

    Robinhood Europe: Private Stock Giveaway Promotion Terms and Conditions (EU)

  28. 28Announced

    ESMA’s executive director said in September 2025 that tokenized stock offerings can give always-on access and fractional amounts but typically give no shareholder rights.

    ESMA: Natasha Cazenave keynote, Tokenisation: an opportunity for the EU’s financial sector agenda?, 1 September 2025

  29. 29Announced

    In the same speech, ESMA’s executive director said this can create a specific risk of investor misunderstanding.

    ESMA: Natasha Cazenave keynote, Tokenisation: an opportunity for the EU’s financial sector agenda?, 1 September 2025

  30. 30Announced

    Canton’s docs say a party with no stake in a transaction never sees it.

    Canton Network docs: Two-Layer Consensus

  31. 31Announced

    CIP-0056, the Canton Network’s token standard, says asset registries maintain the private holding records.

    CIP-0056: Canton Network Token Standard

  32. 32Speculated

    Not confirmed: this is our own assessment. In the parts of the DTC letter, the DTCC release and the Nasdaq order we read, the choice to tokenize sits with DTC’s participants, and we found no step where the listed company agrees. So a Russell 1000 company should assume entitlements to its shares can be tokenized without its act. We didn’t read the full DTC letter word for word.

    Our assessment, from claims 08, 09, 14 and 20

  33. 33Speculated

    Not confirmed: this is our own assessment. A company can’t count tokens of its shares on Canton by looking, because outsiders don’t see private holdings there. For DTC’s service the count sits with DTC, and for any other Canton asset it sits with that asset’s registry. Tokens from third parties on public chains can be looked up by anyone.

    Our assessment, from claims 13, 25, 30 and 31

Open points

  • Whether a listed company has any say in DTC’s service. We read about a third of the SEC staff’s letter word for word and found no issuer step. The rest of the letter and DTC’s own procedures could say more.
  • Which securities have been tokenized through DTC’s service since launch, and how much. DTCC’s release gives the number of participants signed up and says limited-production trades were completed. It names no securities and gives no volumes, and Canton’s privacy means nobody outside can count.
  • How large the third-party tokenized stock market is today. We haven’t opened a primary figure, so this page gives none.
  • What a company can do about a third party’s token it objects to. The SEC staff statement sets out which securities laws apply to the third party. It gives the referenced issuer no stated remedy.
  • Whether the Nasdaq rule is in use. The order approves it, and we haven’t read a notice that tokenized trading under it has started.

What would change this answer

A DTC procedure or SEC filing that gives listed companies a consent or opt-out step would change the answer. So would a Commission rule replacing the staff statement, EU rules on third-party tokenized stocks, or DTCC publishing which securities have been tokenized.

Disclosure from Mac Sibbs

I hold $CC and $CNTN. The full disclosure is on the site.

This page is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Found an error? Write to hello@thegoldenrecord.xyz. Corrections are dated on this page and logged in the corrections log.