Questions / Question 03
Question 03, Operations path
Which record is the legal record of ownership for a tokenised asset on Canton?
For operations and legal leads at a bank or asset manager who are about to hold or issue a tokenised asset on Canton, and who need to know which record they’d rely on in a dispute, an audit or an insolvency.
The short answer
It depends on the asset’s setup. SEC staff describe designs where the ledger is part of the issuer’s ownership file, and others where an off-chain file stays the record. Canton’s token standard, CIP-0056, covers registries that manage ownership records and registries whose authoritative ledger sits outside Canton.
SEC staff set out the designs for US law in January 2026, in a staff statement that carries no legal force. An issuer can build the ledger into its ownership file, so moving the token moves the security. Or it can keep the file off-chain, and the token only prompts changes to it. A third party can also issue a token that stands for a security held in custody. The staff describe synthetic tokens too, which give no rights against the issuer, and we leave those aside. Claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8 and 9.
Canton’s token standard calls a registry the application that manages an asset’s ownership records. It also provides for registries whose authoritative holding records sit outside Canton. DTCC says its tokenization service is integrated with Canton and with its own private network. The SEC staff’s December 2025 letter on DTC’s tokenization services says an off-chain DTC system would be the official books and records. Claims 10, 15, 17, 18 and 19.
The rest of this paragraph is our assessment and sits outside the graded answer. The standard’s word is authoritative, which is a technical term, and it’s silent on legal status. So we read it this way: being on Canton doesn’t settle which record is the legal one, and the answer for your asset sits in its issuance documents, its registry’s terms and the law that governs them. Claims 29 and 30.
One token standard serves registries that keep their records on Canton and registries that keep them elsewhere, so ask which kind your asset uses.
We grade this answer announced. The designs come from an SEC staff statement. The link to Canton rests on the token standard’s own wording, which is the network describing itself, so the answer is graded announced. How we grade.
Taking this to a committee?
We turn the most requested answers into Briefs: the working behind the answer, as files you can edit. This answer stays free either way.
How to find the record for one asset
- Start with the registry. Under CIP-0056, the network’s token standard (a CIP is a Canton Improvement Proposal, the way the network agrees its standards), asset registries are the applications that manage ownership records. In Digital Asset’s registry product the party in charge of an instrument is called the registrar. Claims 17 and 22.
- Ask where that registry keeps its authoritative record. The standard provides for registries that keep it outside Canton. Such a registry may leave holdings off Canton altogether, so they can’t go stale. Claims 18 and 19.
- Match the asset to a design. SEC staff describe one where a transfer on the network results in a transfer of the security on the issuer’s file, and one where the file is off-chain and the token carries none of the security’s rights. Claims 2, 3 and 4.
- Check whether you hold the asset or a claim through someone who does. SEC staff say a token from a third party can expose you to that party’s risks, such as bankruptcy. Separately, the staff’s letter on DTC’s service says it records participants’ security entitlements, and that the securities stay registered to DTC’s nominee. Claims 7, 11 and 12.
- Find out who can change the record without you. The token standard is designed to give registries full control of their workflows and says they’re trusted to maintain the holding records. For DTC’s service, the SEC staff’s letter says DTC would be able to move any token to address errors, lost tokens or wrongdoing. Claims 21, 20 and 13.
- In the EU, read the venue’s permission and its legal terms. Securities traded on a trading venue have to be recorded in book-entry form at a central securities depository. Under the DLT Pilot Regime a depository can ask to be excused from that rule where book-entry doesn’t fit its ledger. The conditions include recording the instruments on the distributed ledger. Permissions run for up to six years, and operators have to publish terms that state the governing law. Claims 24, 26, 27 and 28.
Exhibit 1
Three places the legal record can sit
Design 1
The ledger is the record
The issuer builds the ledger into its ownership file. A transfer on the network results in a transfer of the security. Claim 2.
Trade-off. Ask: do the issuance documents name the ledger as the register?
Design 2
An off-chain file is the record
The security is issued off-chain. The token carries none of its rights and is used to prompt changes to the file. Claims 3 and 4.
Trade-off. Ask: how fast does the file follow the ledger, and which one wins a mismatch?
Design 3
The token stands for a security held in custody
A third party issues a token for a security held in custody. In the SEC staff’s letter on DTC’s service, an off-chain DTC system would be the official record and the securities stay registered to DTC’s nominee. Claims 6, 10 and 12.
Trade-off. Ask: what are your rights against the custodian, and what happens if it fails?
All three designs come from the SEC staff statement, which describes US law and carries no legal force. Other countries draw the lines differently.
The evidence, all 30 claims
14 claims are confirmed, 14 claims are announced and two claims are speculated. The confirmed claims are official texts: an SEC staff statement, which carries no legal force, and two EU regulations. What DTC’s service does is graded announced, because the SEC staff letter repeats DTC’s own description of it. What Canton’s standard and Digital Asset’s docs say about registries is also announced. No source here is a court ruling.
Each claim has its own link, so you can cite it. Sources were opened on 18 November 2026. How we grade.
- 01Confirmed
SEC staff define a tokenized security as a security formatted as or represented by a crypto asset, where the record of ownership is kept in whole or in part on a crypto network.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 02Confirmed
SEC staff describe one issuer design where the ledger is built into the issuer’s master securityholder file, so a transfer of the token on the network results in a transfer of the security on that file.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 03Confirmed
SEC staff describe a second issuer design where the security is issued off-chain and the token carries none of the security’s rights, obligations or benefits.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 04Confirmed
In that second design, SEC staff say the off-chain database records are the master securityholder file.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 05Confirmed
SEC staff say the way holders are recorded, on-chain or off-chain, leaves the application of the federal securities laws unchanged.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 06Confirmed
SEC staff describe a custodial model for tokens from third parties, where the third party issues a token representing the underlying security, such as a tokenized security entitlement.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 07Confirmed
For tokens issued by a third party, SEC staff say holders may be exposed to that third party’s risks, such as bankruptcy, which a holder of the underlying security wouldn’t necessarily face.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 08Confirmed
SEC staff also describe synthetic tokens from third parties, such as a linked security, which is no obligation of the referenced security’s issuer and carries no rights from that issuer.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 09Confirmed
The SEC statement is a staff view. Its own footnote says it’s no rule, regulation, guidance or statement of the Commission.
SEC staff: Statement on Tokenized Securities, 28 January 2026
- 10Announced
The SEC staff’s no-action letter to DTC, the US central securities depository, says on DTC’s stated facts that an off-chain system called LedgerScan would be DTC’s official books and records for tokenized entitlements.
- 11Announced
The same letter describes the service as letting DTC participants have their security entitlements to DTC-held securities recorded using distributed ledger technology.
- 12Announced
The same letter says the securities behind the tokens would stay registered in the name of Cede & Co., DTC’s nominee.
- 13Announced
The same letter says DTC would be able to transfer any of the tokens itself to correct errors, lost tokens or wrongdoing.
- 14Announced
The letter says the staff position is withdrawn three years after DTC launches the first version of the service.
- 15Announced
DTCC said on 28 October 2026 that its tokenization service had launched and was integrated with the Canton Network and DTCC’s own private network.
- 16Announced
DTCC said in July 2026 that assets tokenized by DTC maintain the same investor protections, entitlements and ownership rights as traditional securities.
- 17Announced
CIP-0056, the network’s token standard, describes asset registries as the applications used to manage the ownership records of tokenized assets.
- 18Announced
CIP-0056 provides for registries that keep their authoritative ledger outside Canton, and lets them earmark funds there during a settlement.
- 19Announced
CIP-0056 says a registry whose authoritative holding records sit outside Canton may choose to leave holdings off Canton, to avoid stale records there.
- 20Announced
CIP-0056 says registries are already trusted to maintain the private holding records.
- 21Announced
CIP-0056 lists as a design aim that registries have full control over the workflows that govern holdings and transfers.
- 22Announced
Digital Asset’s Registry docs say the registrar, the party that creates and administers an instrument, is the definitive token administrator for it.
- 23Announced
Texture Capital said in January 2025 that its registered transfer agent would help maintain the official record of ownership for tokenized securities issued on Canton. We haven’t read a later statement of what’s in production.
- 24Confirmed
EU Regulation 909/2014 requires transferable securities traded on a trading venue to be recorded in book-entry form in a central securities depository by the intended settlement date.
- 25Confirmed
The EU’s DLT Pilot Regime says a DLT settlement system should be run by a central securities depository authorised under Regulation 909/2014 that holds a specific permission.
- 26Confirmed
Under the DLT Pilot Regime, a specific permission to operate a DLT settlement system lasts up to six years from issue.
- 27Confirmed
Article 5(2) of the DLT Pilot Regime lets a competent authority exempt a depository operating a DLT settlement system from the book-entry rule in Article 3 of Regulation 909/2014, if, among other conditions, the depository shows book-entry is incompatible with its ledger and makes sure the instruments are recorded on the distributed ledger.
- 28Confirmed
The DLT Pilot Regime requires operators to publish legal terms that state the governing law and any pre-litigation dispute settlement mechanisms.
- 29Speculated
Not confirmed: this is our own assessment. We’ve found nothing in Canton’s token standard or registry docs that decides which record is the legal one. It’s set asset by asset, by the issuer’s documents and the law that governs them. A Canton holding can be the ownership record, a copy of one kept elsewhere, or a claim on a custodian.
Our assessment, from claims 02, 04, 06, 10, 15, 17 and 18
- 30Speculated
Not confirmed: this is our own assessment. Where the documents name an off-chain record, we’d expect that record to win a mismatch with the ledger. We’ve read no court ruling or regulator’s decision that tests this for a Canton asset.
Our assessment, from claims 03, 04, 10 and 13
Open points
- Which design each asset on Canton uses. We’ve found no public list that says, asset by asset, whether the Canton holding is the legal record, a copy or an entitlement. You have to read each issuer’s documents.
- What a court would do with a mismatch. We’ve read no judgment or regulator’s decision on a conflict between a Canton ledger and an off-chain register.
- Non-US, non-EU law. Switzerland, Germany, the UK and others have their own rules on ledger-based registers. We didn’t open those texts in this run, so the page says nothing about them.
- Which EU venues hold a DLT Pilot Regime permission today, and which exemptions each was given. We read the exemption in Article 5(2) and haven’t checked the permissions granted under it.
What would change this answer
A Commission rule or court ruling on tokenized ownership records, a change to DTC’s no-action relief, an EU decision to make the DLT Pilot Regime permanent or let it lapse, or a CIP that makes on-ledger holdings authoritative for every registry would each change this answer.
Disclosure from Mac Sibbs
I hold $CC and $CNTN. The full disclosure is on the site.
This page is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Found an error? Write to hello@thegoldenrecord.xyz. Corrections are dated on this page and logged in the corrections log.